Gollum is hardly an argument against computers in movies. That is what makes Andy Serkis’s warning about an AI version interesting: the actor behind the creature is defending the person inside the pixels, not demanding that Hollywood unplug everything.
What Serkis actually said
In an interview with Andrew Marr, released by LBC’s Global Player on November 10 and reported by LBC on November 11, Serkis argued that AI-generated versions of characters such as Gollum or King Kong would not match an actor’s performance.
His concern was authorship: the interpretation and choices a person brings to a role. He also acknowledged useful applications for AI in film. This was not a declaration that every digital tool is an enemy of acting.
Peter Jackson’s argument makes the line more complicated
Back in May, Peter Jackson told a Cannes masterclass that he did not object to AI as a filmmaking effect. He emphasized permission for uses of an actor’s likeness, while defending Serkis’s Gollum as a human performance rather than an AI-generated one.
Those comments are older context, not a new response to Serkis. Nor do they establish a feud. Both leave room for technology; the difficult question is what it is being asked to replace.
MOAN’s take: a convincing face is not the whole performance
Our view is that the argument gets less useful when “AI” becomes shorthand for every computer-assisted image. A tool that helps artists finish a shot and a system used to replace a performer raise different questions about creative control, consent and credit.
The strongest opposing case deserves a hearing: if filmmakers deliberately direct and shape a result, why must using a new tool make it artistically worthless? Audiences may care most about whether a scene moves them, not the software involved.
But a convincing result alone does not answer who agreed to participate or whose contribution disappears from the credits. We would rather judge the process as well as the picture. Paying for permission and keeping humans meaningfully in control are better starting points than treating an actor as an expensive inconvenience.
Would you accept an AI-assisted Gollum if the actor remained in control, or is replacing any part of the performance a line you would not cross?
Watch the interview
Watch Andy Serkis discuss AI and acting with Andrew Marr on LBC’s official Global Player video page.
Featured image: Andy Serkis at the July 2017 San Diego Comic-Con Black Panther panel, photographed by Gage Skidmore, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.5. Used as supplied, without additional edits in this article. The accompanying MOAN promotional card crops/resizes the photograph and adds a headline layout; the adapted photograph is shared under CC BY-SA 2.5. This archival event portrait is not from the November 2026 interview.